Centers Choice Home Care

    75 Vanderbilt Ave, Staten Island, NY 10304

    Patient, Reliable, Respectful, Compassionate Caregivers

    I've used this agency for almost two years and am very satisfied. Caregivers are patient, kind, and respectful of religious needs; staff are reachable and responsive, with dependable coverage (even through COVID) and reliable emergency fills. Walton was a great, patient trainer. Professional, compassionate care at a reasonable price - I recommend them.

    Loved one of client
    May 2026

    Services

    • Home Health Care

    Reviews

    3.91·(22)

    Overall rating

    1. 5
    2. 4
    3. 3
    4. 2
    5. 1
    • Caregivers

      4.0
    • Communication

      3.0
    • Reliability

      3.7
    • Scheduling

      3.0
    • Value

      3.0

    Pros

    • Patient, friendly caregivers
    • Compassionate and respectful care
    • Professional and punctual caregivers
    • Responsive office communication
    • Reliable emergency and backup coverage
    • Long-term caregiver continuity
    • Effective caregiver training and orientation
    • Good caregiver-client matching
    • Respect for cultural and religious preferences
    • Reasonable pricing

    Cons

    • Inconsistent caregiver assignments
    • Unreliable shift coverage (cancellations and mid-shift departures)
    • Office communication lapses and missed callbacks
    • Variable care quality
    • Management professionalism concerns
    • Pricing and value inconsistency

    Summary of reviews

    The reviews present a mixed but informative picture. Many families describe high-quality direct care: caregivers are often characterized as patient, compassionate, professional and punctual, with several reviewers praising strong caregiver-client matching, respectful handling of cultural and religious needs, and effective orientation and training programs. There are multiple comments about responsive office communication via phone and email, and distinct positive notes about dependable emergency and backup coverage, including during COVID-era staffing pressures. A number of clients also described long-term relationships with aides, which suggests the agency can sustain caregiver continuity for some placements.

    Counterbalancing those positives are recurring operational concerns. A pattern of inconsistent caregiver assignments and variable care quality emerges across the feedback: while some clients had stable, excellent aides, others experienced gaps in attentiveness and service standards. Staffing reliability is an area of particular divergence—reports include reliable emergency fills alongside last-minute cancellations and mid-shift departures. These items suggest that backup-staffing processes work well in some cases but are not uniformly effective.

    Office- and management-level issues appear in several comments. Although the agency is described as reachable and quick to respond by many, other reviewers cite missed callbacks, unhelpful coordinators, and interactions they perceived as unprofessional or disrespectful toward caregivers. This indicates inconsistency in front-office conduct and coordination practices rather than a single uniform experience. Pricing and perceived value are also mixed: some clients called the service reasonably priced, while others described it as costly, pointing to variability in client expectations or in how services are quoted and billed.

    Overall pattern: the agency demonstrates clear strengths in caregiver warmth, training, and in some instances dependable emergency coverage, but also shows variability in scheduling reliability, care consistency, and office professionalism. Prospective clients and families would benefit from direct, specific questions about caregiver turnover, backup-staffing protocols, cancellation policies, and billing transparency before engaging services. Asking for references from current families and confirming the agency’s standard procedures for mid-shift coverage and coordinator escalation may help set expectations and reduce the chance of the negative experiences described.

    Location

    Map showing location of Centers Choice Home Care

    Centers Choice Home Care is located at 75 Vanderbilt Ave, Staten Island, NY 10304.

    People often ask...

    Disclaimer

    Mirador Home Care is not affiliated with the owner or operator(s) of Centers Choice Home Care. The information on this page is provided as a public resource and may not reflect the most current details. For exact information, please contact Centers Choice Home Care directly. There is no cost for using this service.

    Nearby Home Care Agencies

    Home Care in Nearby Cities

    1. 0 agencies
    2. 1 agencies
    3. 4 agencies
    4. 3 agencies
    5. 0 agencies
    6. 12 agencies
    7. 1 agencies
    8. 3 agencies
    9. 3 agencies
    10. 4 agencies
    11. 4 agencies
    12. 0 agencies
    Mirador

    Helping families find trusted in-home care services. Your guide to quality home care.

    Company

    Home care services

    © 2025 Mirador Home Care